“I'm not a big fan of psychoanalysis: I think if you have
mental problems what you need are good pills. But I do think that if you have
thinks that bother you, things that are unresolved, the more that you talk
about them, write about them, the less serious they become.” –Stephen King
Sigmund Freud instituted us with the idea of Psychoanalysis. It is
grounded in multiple parts. Parts include: a person’s development are based on
his or her childhood, actions are caused by the unconscious mind, the mind
creates defense mechanisms to repress memories, and repressed memories can be
brought back to the conscious through coaching. However, I would like to argue
a point here that I do not necessarily believe, so please bare with me.
I am not a believer in medicine. I hate medicine; I do not take it at
all costs. I believe in natural recovery. The most recent time that I
experienced the issue of medication was when I sustained me spell of
concussions last year. After suffering through anxiety and depression issues
after my concussions, I was told by doctors that I needed medication to help
me. I am proud to say that aside from an occasional Advil, I took no medication
to aid my recovery. If this were to happen again, I would not take medication.
However, it is interesting to look at what would happen if I did take
medication.
Stephen King would be on the side of medication in my case. However,
Freud would not be. Freud would argue that I should have sought counseling to
talk about my issues to get through my anxiety and depression. Fortunately that
is what I did, and it did help me significantly. But it is always interesting
to wonder about the other side. If I did take medication, my recovery could
have been expedited. But that was never an option for me. I am extremely happy
where I ended up.
As a student in high school, I am an outsider to what medication can
really do to you. My dad likes to act as an expert in the field; he is far from
it. He works with computers, not medication. He is the driving force against me
taking meds. However, he is also an outsider to the fact. He has read many
books on psychology. He has also read some books on Freud. He agrees with Freud’s
psychoanalytical theory. He is the one that suggested I should seek counseling
instead of medication. This brings up the point, should you listen to a large
group of outsiders? I could have listened to my doctors, who I would consider
the insiders on the topic. However, I instead listened to a group of outsiders,
who knew little about concussions. In the end, I turned out all right.
I would quickly like to also make the point that every person is an
outsider when it comes to the topic of concussions. No one really knows a thing
about concussions. Each one is different, and concussions are ever evolving.
The field is expanding, but after suffering my own fair share of concussions, I
would not even consider a neurologist an insider on concussions.
I'm really interested about your comparison here between natural recovery and medication. I wrote a blog post about this recently regarding how ADHD is overdiagnosed in our society. I'm glad that you ended up choosing natural recovery in your situation. I think our society has become quite dependent on medication. Yes, medication is certainly helpful for certain illnesses and perhaps a necessity in some cases, however the typical response from doctors is to automatically offer medication to quickly "fix" the problem. In many ways, connecting this back to my post about ADHD, it was found to be more effective to teach patients with ADHD skills that would help them better live their lives with ADHD, rather than showering them with medications that would temporarily mask their condition. I think this gets at your experience with the more natural experience. I think that psychology certainly plays a part in wellness and as you even said, it helped you, in part, with getting better. I would definitely consider researching this topic further...very captivating idea.
ReplyDeleteTo me medication is not a long term solution. While it may be that quick fix, medication can wear off over time. Our bodies can either become overly dependent on medication, or our bodies can reject the medication. Either case is not good for our bodies. More times than not, doctors prescribe different medication, and more and more medication is used. If people were to not rely on medicine, single long term solutions may be possible. Natural recover can be scary because there are no certain guarentees. However, there are also no guarentees with medicine. Natural recovery may take longer, but it will allow the body to fight off whatever needs to be fought off by itself.
ReplyDelete